Skip to main content
View all newsletters
Subscribe to newsletter notifications

Learning Connects No.17

Elevating education: insights from the Torino Process 2023

Towards excellence in teaching in the EU neighbourhood: insights from the Torino Process

Pedagogical skills, subject knowledge, and an eagerness to adapt and update them in response to challenges and opportunities in the surrounding environment are essential for today’s educators. They also need strong social skills, whether engaging face to face or virtually with learners, as ...

Pedagogical skills, subject knowledge, and an eagerness to adapt and update them in response to challenges and opportunities in the surrounding environment are essential for today’s educators.

They also need strong social skills, whether engaging face to face or virtually with learners, as the societal issues of the world at large, such as migration, are played out in the classroom microcosm.

The ETF, an Agency of the EU working on human capital development in its neighbouring regions, is working together with country counterparts to better understand and respond to the skills development of educators and learners. It undertakes regular monitoring of system-wide progress in education and training, as well as targeted studies and surveys on key components as with educators. The results are intended to guide policy refinement, resource allocation, and strategy formulation with the well-being and success of learners at the centre.

The Torino Process is a biennial review of vocational education and training systems within a lifelong learning perspective. It was established by the European Training Foundation (ETF) in 2010 and since then has been carried out in partner countries in South Eastern Europe, Türkiye, Eastern Europe, Central Asia and the Southern and Eastern Mediterranean.

The 6th round of the Torino Process 2022 -2024 monitoring exercise examined many of the deliverables of vocational education and training systems including better conditions of work for teachers and staff in leadership positions in education and training. It introduced a novel monitoring exercise across 22 countries focusing on system performance and lifelong learning, in particular the degree to which countries create and sustain good and equitable opportunities for lifelong learning, and the impact which initial and continuing VET has on the educational and career paths of youth and adult individuals.

The emphasis has been on excellence in teaching and the professional growth of educators, the integration of innovative practices to boost the quality and relevance of teachers work in support of learning and training, the competence of VET school leaders, and the efficiency in managing human resources allocated to the system, particularly the availability and proper deployment of teachers and trainers.

The 2023 monitoring delivered a mixed message in these areas. The results point out both positive trends, such as the improvement in learning quality and efforts to align education with labour market demands, as well as areas of concern or at least room for improvement. Examples include the presence of gaps in leadership capacity across countries, only moderate emphasis on pedagogical excellence despite commitments to the contrary, and moderate efficiency in managing human resources. 

Good leaders and good teachers are essential for the quality of learning. The findings regarding innovation in support of better and more relevant teaching are positive as quite a few countries in the Torino Process sample report being open to innovative practices in this domain. Yet, in many contexts the system-wide uptake of innovative solutions remains a challenge.

Additionally, results indicate that countries are only moderately efficient in managing their human resources in VET. In many, policies and practices to recruit and retain qualified teachers and trainers and ensure their effective allocation and utilization across various institutions and programmes, may need attention. This is also true for the scheduling and management of their workload and career progression so that they have better conditions and support to meet VET-specific objectives and equip students with skills.

Drawing upon the experience and expertise of key experts this 17th edition of Learning Connects focuses on ways to overcome system wide difficulties featured in the Torino Process findings including support for teacher empowerment and engagement in policy dialogue, discussion on contemporary challenges, such as artificial intelligence, and better understanding of educators professional development needs and supporting tools. 

Giving teachers a voice: Interview with the ETF's Julian Stanley

Ensuring teachers are heard: interview with the ETF's Julian Stanley

A journey to revolutionise education. Explore how educators are reshaping the future of learning!

Julian Stanley has been coordinating the ETF’s thinking on vocational education and training (VET) teachers and trainers since 2014, with a special focus on their professional development. Giving teachers a voice in educational policy and reform has been a constant theme of his work ever building on his previous experience as a VET trainer and researcher. 

“People are starting to wake up to how teachers feel,” he says. “They’re real people, just like you and me. They’re not just tools to do the will of policy-makers.” 

Listening to teachers 

That insight was the driving force behind the recent large-scale survey that Julian developed and ran for the ETF, entitled Listening to Vocational Teachers and Principals. The results of its second cycle – conducted in Albania, Algeria, Belarus, Kosovo, Moldova, Montenegro, Serbia, Tunisia and Turkey between 2018 and 2019 – were published in 2021. “The idea was listening to how VET teachers and principals perceived their experiences and needs, and discovering how reforms were impacting them,” says Julian.  

Essential resource 

If that approach appears to turn the classic top-down approach to policy-making on its head, it is entirely intentional. “Teachers and trainers are the critical resource for successful education and training,” Julian explains. “If you want to make changes, you need to have them on board.”  

That realisation is gaining more traction today, partly as a result of the COVID pandemic. “The experience of the pandemic put teachers under such pressure that they got a bit disillusioned,” says Julian. “It gave them a lot of extra work, they felt unsupported, and they let the world know. That marked a critical shift. It undermined the assumption that you can just go on asking teachers to do more and more.” 

Fostering engagement 

So how can we foster teacher engagement with the far-reaching transitions underway in the modern world? For Julian, the answer is by addressing their professional development. “It’s critical,” he explains. “We have to empower and enable teachers to address the problem, whatever it is.” 

Today, those changes may be imposed suddenly by the external environment – like COVID – or they may take place in a more anticipated fashion, like the Digital Transition. Like the Green Transition, they may even be intentionally willed by our societies. But in all cases, they require motivated teachers to be managed successfully. “It’s very important to look at models of professional development that take the experience, motivation and commitment of teachers into account,” says Julian. “If you don’t, you’re missing out on an essential resource.” 

Feel-good factor 

That means capitalizing on the things that motivated teachers to become teachers in the first place. “They’re usually very public-spirited people,” Julian explains. “The question is: how can we go about harnessing that enthusiasm? Are there ways of empowering teachers to take on leadership roles among their peers? How can we make teachers feel good about themselves, by recognizing their additional skills? We believe these are effective ways of enabling teachers to react to the challenges taking place in and outside education, now and in the immediate future.” 

International dimension 

Today the ETF is acting on these insights, with projects that empower teachers to take the lead in their own professional development. And as ever, the ETF’s commitment to international collaboration is a crucial part of the equation. “A lot of what we’re trying to do is to share solutions from country to country,” says Julian.  

One means of doing just that is the International Self-Assessment Tool for CoVEs (ISATCOVE), whose development Julian is currently leading. ISATCOVE – whose pilot project has just been launched in Slovenia – enables Centres of Vocational Excellence (CoVEs) to review their own activities and structures in the light of what other vocational schools are doing, thus fostering international best practice. “It’s all about fostering new ways of bringing teachers together – both within schools and across schools – so they can feel able to meet the challenges of today,” he explains. 

For Julian Stanley and everyone else at the ETF, that is a challenge well worth taking.  

ETF Ready model

READY for rollout – A model for 21st century educators

READY is an innovative pedagogical model developed by the European Training Foundation to help educators respond to transformations in the world...

READY is an innovative pedagogical model developed by the European Training Foundation to help educators respond to transformations in the world and in education. It was developed as part of the ETF's Creating New Learning initiative. Over the past year it has been tested, and has sparked interest and enthusiasm. Now the user-friendly digital toolkit is being rolled out to educators across ETF partner countries in the EU's neighbouring regions.

“Educators can use the model as a source of inspiration to enhance their teaching and learning practices, and therefore enhance the learning experiences of their students and, hopefully, their learning outcomes,” says Jolien van Uden, a human capital development expert at the ETF and leader of READY.

The model’s main focus is on teachers across the education system, in vocational education and training, in primary and secondary schools and also in post-school education and training, company-based and lifelong learning.

Jolien Van UdenIt can be used, for example, to reflect on and improve current teaching and learning practices; to support observations and obtain peer feedback; to gauge strengths and weaknesses; and to help educators identify and meet their professional development needs.

“It is important to emphasise that it is not the sole responsibility of educators to develop professionally in all domains. It is imperative to create an environment in which educators are able to excel,” Van Uden says. “An environment that provides support and guidance, but also career opportunities, recognition and high quality professional development opportunities.

“To support this, READY can also be used as source of inspiration by school leaders, teacher trainers and policy-makers” – anyone working closely with or working to support educators.

The notion of a ‘21st century educator’ emerged from READY research. It is an umbrella term for a large and diverse group of professionals involved in teaching or guiding and facilitating learning.

READY is a ‘living’ model that will adapt and grow in the coming years, as will the educators who use it. It provides a structured way to identify the professional praxes and development needs of modern educators, as well as user-friendly tools to support their work and encourage teaching innovation. It helps educators get up to speed with educational changes.

The model is flexible and customisable, and can be used in different contexts and translated into any language. In the past year READY has also been released in Arabic, Russian and Ukrainian. Some European Union countries have requested translations. As READY operates under a Creative Commons licence, people can use it in any way and change it freely.

Getting READY for wide release

There is confidence in the quality of READY, which is rooted in theory, literature and research. Its approach and pedagogy have been thoroughly reviewed.

How the model works in practice has been tested under a Partnership on Innovation in Teaching and Learning with Israel, conducted through the Amal and Ort education networks. It aimed to develop a ‘New Educator Profile in a Changing World’ for the Israeli education system.

The pilot presented “very promising” findings in July, and concluded that READY is a leading model in many education spheres – pedagogy, curriculum, management, professional development and more – and could provide a positive contribution to the education system.

“The teachers are very enthusiastic, saying that they are really changing some things in their practice,” Van Uden says. The pilot results will be presented in a webinar on 13 November.

The ETF is also providing more resources for the model, for instance through blogs in its online Open Space platform, each focusing on a different READY domain. One blog explored how to enhance teaching with digital technologies. A second looked at how to create inclusive learning environments and promote sustainability.

It is not easy being a teacher. Educators are under constant performance pressure. 

Van Uden concludes: “And so we hope the READY model will support educators to reflect on their practices, to feel encouraged and to maybe start trying out new things – but also finding confirmation about the things they’re already doing.”

See the video below to find out more.

 

Spotlight on ETF live: Teachers VS AI

Artificial intelligence, green skills, and more. A month of events relevant to teachers

In case you’ve missed it… ETF live ‘Teachers vs AI’

A lively debate on the role of teachers in the era of artificial intelligence. Are teachers ready to take on AI in the classroom? Can AI be the perfect classroom assistant for both educators and learners? Or will AI threaten the quality of education? 

Listen to this live conversation to get some reflections on these challenging issues.

 

Green Skills Award 2023 – Update

The 10 finalists of our Green Skills Award competition were announced early June, and the public vote is about to be closed (29 September, 23:59 CEST). Thank you all for casting your votes. The winner will be announced in late October/November, so stay tuned!

 

Events
World Teachers’ Day, 5 October

Let’s celebrate teachers around the world! This year, World Teachers’ Day focus on the theme ‘The teachers we need for the education we want: The global imperative to reverse the teacher shortage’.

Find out how to register to join UNESCO’s event online – Day 1  Day 2

Skills Lab Network of Experts 2023 Live Event: Skills (R)evolution: Understanding and developing skills for a digital era, 9–10 October

A two-day event that will provide the Skills Lab Network members with an opportunity to exchange and learn about the latest developments in skills analysis, and imagine a pathway towards a digital future.

Find out how to join the Skills Lab Network

European Vocational Skills Week, 23–27 October

Launched by the European Commission in 2016, the European Vocational Skills Week seeks to promote vocational education and training (VET) as an attractive career and personal development pathway by bringing stakeholders together to showcase VET opportunities and inspiring best practices.

Your voice, questions and feedback

Your voice, questions and feedback

Do you have ideas or questions about our newsletter? We would love to hear from you! Take a moment to share your feedback with us

Do you have ideas or questions about our newsletter? We would love to hear from you! Take a moment to share your feedback with us

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Youtube
  • LinkedIn
  • Instagram

Copyright © European Training Foundation, All rights reserved.